The 2nd Investigative Commission on Procurement Reform of Digital Agency Information Systems in Fiscal 2026
- Last Updated:
Outline
For an overview of the Study Group, please refer to the 2026 Digital Agency Information Systems Acquisition Reform Study Group .
Event Information
- Date and Time: October 21, 2026 (Wed) 11:30 to 13:00
- Location: Online (Microsoft Teams)
- Attending Committee members: Chairman Shoji, Committee Members Ishikawa, Kawasawa and Shiroyama
Proceedings
- 1. Opening
- 2. Proceedings
- 1. Review of the previous review meeting
- 2. Measures taken in the past fiscal year
- 2.1 Final evaluation of "Improving the Agile and Flexible Procurement Process" and explanation of evaluation perspective
- 2.2 Open Discussion
- 2.3 Final evaluation of "Capability Enhancement of Outsourcer Side in System Procurement" and explanation on evaluation viewpoints
- 2.4 Final evaluation of "Expansion of Opportunities for Entry by SMEs and Startup Companies, etc." and explanation of the perspective of the evaluation
- 2.5 Open Discussion
- 2.6 Explanation on the final evaluation of "Elimination of vender lock-in" and the viewpoint of evaluation
- 2.7 Final evaluation of "Ensuring Transparency through Internal Controls, etc." and explanation of the viewpoints of evaluation
- 2.8 Open Discussion
- 3. Reorganization of and free discussion on issues related to concepts for new information system procurement reform measures that take into account the recent changes in the environment surrounding information systems
- 3) Closing
Data
- Proceedings (PDF/131KB)
- Data Submitted by the Secretariat (PDF/3,485 kb)
- Summary of the 2nd Meeting of the Investigative Commission for Procurement Reform of Digital Agency Information Systems in Fiscal 2026 (PDF / 241 kb)
Summary of the proceedings
After the Secretariat explained the final evaluation of the measures implemented in FY 2024 and FY 2025, the direction of future measures, a new evaluation system, and candidate priority issues of the Information Systems Procurement Reform Measures, discussions took place and the main opinions from each member were as follows.
1. Validity evaluation of measures taken in the past fiscal year
(1) Overall
Evaluation should focus not only on the number of implemented policies, but also on whether the systems and support measures have changed actual procurement behavior and whether the value of administrative services has been sustainably realized at a reasonable cost.
- When evaluating the results of measures, it is possible to use both individual projects and organizations as evaluation units. It is necessary to share data among multiple divisions, including the division in charge of the system, as well as the division in charge of the procurement system, and to evaluate based on the division of roles.
- The evaluation system cannot be applied only to Digital Agency; it needs to be designed so that it can be applied to other ministries and agencies.
- The direction of evaluating business performance and quality is reasonable, but it is necessary to specify who, what, when, and how to measure. It is also possible to combine evaluation by comparing the start and end of an individual project with fixed-point observation to confirm the effects of measures over the long term.
- The cooperation of divisions actually engaged in business is essential for the evaluation of business performance. A system that cannot be implemented without incurring a huge cost for divisions that individually collect results will not take root. Therefore, an evaluation method that can be continued by the organization without excessive burden must be established.
- For indicators that require the judgment of the evaluator, such as the achievement rate of important proposals, it is necessary to clarify what is important and what is judged as achievement, and to consider an operational method that can utilize the measurement results for policy improvement.
(2) Direction of measures (1) "Improvement of agile and flexible procurement procedures"
- When promoting agile development, do not aim to establish a specialized department. First, through small-scale demonstration, it is necessary to verify the method of reflecting specification changes during development in the contract, the acceptance inspection method, the payment method according to progress or results, and the decision-making body when costs increase or results are not achieved, and to proceed with consensus building step by step.
- Agile development using AI has the potential to quickly compare multiple design proposals and continuously improve administrative services according to users' needs, while staff are required to judge requirements, quality control, security, and laws and regulations suitability, and to review estimates based on person-month rates, contracts, acceptance inspections, payments, responsibility sharing, and change control.
- Development using AI should not be evaluated only on the basis of whether it can be carried out quickly and at low cost. It is necessary to evaluate the cost effectiveness of the entire life cycle, including systems that can continue to individualize development, maintain, respond to vulnerabilities, and apply patches.
(3) Direction of measures (ii) "Improving capabilities of orderers in system procurement"
- It is necessary to define the capability of the ordering party by distinguishing between the stage at which the party has the knowledge and the stage at which the party can use the knowledge in the actual project, make a judgment by itself, and implement the decision. Knowledge transfer and utilization should be evaluated based on whether procurement quality was maintained or whether the same judgment could be reproduced after personnel changes, rather than based on the number of FAQ views and the number of training participants.
- It is necessary to distinguish whether problems in procurement are caused by the ability of employees or by the system, budget or contract procedures, and to clarify who is responsible for improvement with regard to problems that require systemic response.
- The purpose should not be a contact point or a FAQ, but to build a process that enables staff to carry out procurement on their own through practice, advice and reflection in actual projects.
- When evaluating the capability of the ordering party, after defining the capability required of the procuring division and the status of appropriate function, it is necessary to organize the evaluating entities and the evaluation method. In this case, it is important to have not only the procuring division but also a wide range of parties concerned, including users such as the divisions in charge of the system.
- A focus solely on avoiding past mistakes and rework may discourage start-ups and the adoption of new technologies. Trials needed to adapt to new technologies and environments should be evaluated in the light of the value and costs that will result.
(4) Direction of measures (iii) "Expanding entry opportunities for SMEs and start-up companies"
- It is necessary to move from the evaluation of whether the opportunity for entry of SMEs and start-up companies has been expanded to the stage of verifying whether the value of government procurement has been enhanced by the expansion of entry. It is necessary to comprehensively evaluate whether the value of overall procurement has been enhanced by checking not only the number of participating companies and the number of bids but also the diversity of price, quality, and technology, respectively.
- It is necessary for new entrants to confirm the quality and delivery time after receiving an order, as well as the improvement of administrative services through the adoption of new technologies and services.
- For the companies that have abandoned their application, it is necessary to consider improvement measures based on a wide range of information, including not only the requirements such as qualification to participate in competitions and ISMAP, but also the size of the project, the burden of preparing a proposal, the payment conditions, and the timing of the announcement of the procurement schedule.
- Improvement of the entry environment for SMEs and start-up companies should not end with temporary measures, but should be designed as a mechanism that leads to continuous improvement of the quality of procurement.
(5) Direction of measures ④ "Elimination of vender lock-in"
- Vender lock-in should not be limited to the issue of unilateral bidding, but should be understood as an issue of portability, i.e., whether it is possible to switch to a different provider when necessary. It should be confirmed that not only the actual switching results but also the data, API, design information, operational procedures, etc. are reflected in the specifications and contracts, and that the transition conditions are ensured.
- Exit requirements should be established in a phased manner, taking into account the importance of the system, the availability of alternative carriers, and transition costs, so as to avoid excessive requirements that would increase funding costs and burdens on carriers.
- Rather than regarding vender lock-in as a uniform issue, it is also necessary to confirm the advantages of long-term contracts and continuous relationships with the same operator, such as the accumulation of know-how, price effects, relationships of trust and the reduction of communication costs. The relationship between the advantages of continuous use and the possibility of switching to another operator and the costs required for switching should be evaluated throughout the life cycle.
- With regard to the elimination of vender lock-in, it is necessary to evaluate from the perspective of whether options have been secured rather than the number of carriers, and to confirm competitiveness and flexibility not only at the point of purchase but also throughout the lifecycle.
(6) Direction of measures (v) "Ensuring Transparency through Internal Controls, etc."
- For ensuring internal control and transparency, it is necessary to design a mechanism that can explain not only the fairness of the procedure at the time of contracting, but also that the flexible response after the contract was fair and appropriate.
- For post-contract changes, it is necessary to record the reason for the change, the difference from the initial assumption, the approver, the time of approval, and the basis for the decision, so that they can be verified after the fact. In addition, the criteria for determining changes that are handled under normal contract management, changes that require additional examination, and changes that are considered for replacement should be organized.
- As it is difficult to draw a clear line for flexible judgment across the board, a process is needed to accumulate individual cases and to form explainable criteria and practices through reflection and sharing.
- An overemphasis on avoiding mistakes and rework will shrink the field and make it difficult to experiment with flexible procurement. A mechanism is needed to protect experimental initiatives so that the field can try out new initiatives to a certain extent and revise them through reviews as necessary.
- In order to ensure fairness and accountability, it is necessary to consider how to ensure the effectiveness of the recording and judgment process, including external confirmation by sampling, as well as developing a recording form.
- There is a need to assess whether transparency and accountability have actually improved, rather than just having systems and records in place, and to design governance and operational processes that balance transparency with agility.
2. Concept of new information system procurement reform measures
(1) Structure of Priority Issues and Method of Deliberation
- It is necessary not only to discuss the five priority issues individually, but also to consider them as a common reform cycle that links the purpose, efforts, confirmation of effects, and reflection in the next procurement.
- Rather than adding new issues, it is necessary to move on to discussions that specify the demonstration project, evaluation indicators, judgment criteria, responsible parties, and methods of reflecting them in the next procurement.
- It is necessary to organically connect each priority issue and clarify how the issues to be dealt with at each meeting of the Study Group are related. On the other hand, it is possible not to stick to discussing the five priority issues in order, but to make the order and structure easy to discuss based on the relationship between the issues.
- Since the implementation of the reform itself involves costs and practical burdens, it is necessary to confirm the implementation difficulty of each issue, necessary resources, and feasibility of government-wide implementation. It is necessary to study the implementation system by distinguishing the matters that can be dealt with by Digital Agency providing guidelines, and the matters that require continuous follow-up involving other ministries.
- It is necessary to study not only the matters that should be implemented immediately, but also the ideal form of systems and markets from a medium - to long-term perspective. With regard to the government information system procurement market, it is also necessary to have a perspective on how to form a market with growth potential for business operators, based on structural conditions such as the budget system, personnel changes, and the market size of the government and local governments.
(2) Reforming procurement and contract models
- Procurement and contracting models need to be evaluated in terms of not only the cost of change, but also full life-cycle costs, quality and benefits to users.
- In the governance of the overall procurement, it is necessary to clarify the distinction between a mechanism that can absorb cost fluctuations within a certain range and matters that should be separately determined as additional costs. It is also necessary to have a mechanism for managing costs so that costs do not increase without limit due to the acceptance of flexible changes.
(3) Ensuring competitiveness and technological options, and the impact on market formation
- With regard to competitiveness and market formation, it is necessary to check the diversity of price, quality and technology respectively, and to check what effects have been achieved by technology that cannot be adopted by conventional procurement methods.
(4) Procurement Ensuring Digital Resilience
- With regard to digital resilience, it is necessary to check not only recovery time but also the recovery status of data, alternative means, and the continuity of critical operations.
(5) Securing knowledge circulation in the public and private sectors and expertise of orderers
- With regard to knowledge circulation in the public and private sectors and the expertise of outsourcers, it is necessary to check not the quantity of accumulated knowledge, but its utilization in actual projects, maintenance and improvement of procurement quality, and reproducibility after personnel changes.
(6) Procurement and AI Governance for generative AI
- For procurements based in generative AI, it is necessary to evaluate not only the improvement of production efficiency, but also security, information management, rights, burden of verification of deliverables, and operation and maintenance.
(7) Future considerations
- "Among measures taken in the past fiscal year, it is necessary to evaluate not only the status of development of systems and environment, but also the degree of contribution to the quality of procurement and the improvement of administrative services."
- As for new reform measures, it is necessary to concretize not only individual priority issues but also medium - and long-term systems, markets, human resources, costs, and implementation systems.
- *The committee members' opinions include those submitted in advance.
Greater Than